Shia Online CommunityShia OnlineCommunity
Najafi Q&A: Theses and Dissertations

Recently, there have been increasing calls for specialization in ijtihad (Islamic jurisprudential reasoning),…

Q&A⚖️ Fiqh & Law

Recently, there have been increasing calls for specialization in ijtihad (Islamic jurisprudential reasoning), meaning that a jurist should be a mujtahid (qualified jurist) in a specific area or set of issues in fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence). What is your opinion on this matter?

Answer

In the name of Allah, First, it should be understood that anyone who has engaged in true ijtihad knows that specialization in Islamic jurisprudence is not reasonable according to scholarly standards. Second, if specialization is assumed, then the jurist who specializes in one area of fiqh would be ignorant and a muqallid (follower) in the remaining areas. The evidences that permit taqlid (emulation) do not apply to him, and in fact, the permissibility of a fragmented jurist (al-faqih al-mutajazzi’) acting upon his own fatwa is a matter of scholarly debate. Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

added 8/29/2026

Comments (0)

No comments yet.