1. What is your Eminence’s opinion if the Husseini speakers and/or chanters who ask for specific amounts of…

Answer

1. In the name of Allah, holding events on the master of martyrs and other Imams PBUH), preaching and guiding are required. There are three categories: a. the Husseini preacher may specify the amount and may wish an increase for the sake of being respected and liked by people. In this case, the Husseini speaker tries to benefit the people in that he tries to increase his audience to learn what he spent most of his life learning. This person entitled to have the good in this world and the hereafter, regarding preaching and guiding. b. The Husseini speaker charges as a source of living for him and his family and for the expensive books he buys. This one is allowed for claiming money and will receive reward as well. c. The Husseini speaker takes the Husseini cause as a trade to earn from just like any constructor hired for constructing a house or mosques building. This person has only the money he will receive. Still, it is permissible for this person to do that. A.2. In the name of Allah, if this person should explain certain rules or refute certain religious doubts and faith, ten it is not permissible for him to do that if he can do the duty in this regard. If it is not this case, it is his choice to be one of the abovementioned categories. Allah is the all-knowing and guide.