How do you respond to this reasoning: If we ask: What does Allah want from people? Through which way does He…
How do you respond to this reasoning: If we ask: What does Allah want from people? Through which way does He want them to worship him? We find no religion to us except two ways: the first is to follow a religious authority (marji) and the second is to research and be a mujtahid. There is no other way of religion. This means that Allah wants one of these two according to the logic of the religious. As for following a marji, there is no doubt that there is no suspicion about its nullity, and that is the consensus of the religion scholars and others. It is not possible that Allah wants the sons of every religion to follow their fathers in their religion. All that remains is the need to seek out the true religion and to be religious. However, the search for true religion requires conditions that are not available in any one: It is necessary to study all contemporary and ancient religious schools and religions and study them in depth, to know their confessions, to compare their scholars, and to balance the statements of each religion with each other. This study requires studying the sciences, literature, languages, reading books, criticizing them, comparing them, and saving travel costs, research costs, and purchasing books with the time and qualities that must be available in the researcher such as science, mind, dream, honesty and patience. This is what great men cannot do throughout their lives. It is absolutely impossible How to ask adolescent children in puberty?! The jurists have decided in their jurisprudential research that the disability nullifies the commitment. Searching for the true religion is not obligatory because it is not possible. If the obligation to seek the religion is nullified, then the religion must be nullified too. Thus, you will get from the above that the religious has got only two options, not the other: either following a marji and it is in addition to nullification we make sure that Allah does not want and does not ask anyone to follow his people in their religion. Or searching for the true religion with its proper conditions, a matter which is absolutely inconceivable. This means that Allah does not want anyone to be religious at all with any religion ... If Allah wanted people to have a particular religion, why has not he made them a true path, : as mentioned in the Quranic verse: (And there is no embarrassment on you in religion) and any greater embarrassment than we are asking a true, easy path to religion, we do not find! If we recognize that the search for religion is the right way to religion because we do not agree on that; the search for the right religion is not a true path and not safe for religion because the researcher is not an infallible and the occurrence in error, negligence, suspicion and the predominance of instincts and desires are possible. If a researcher searches for the right religion and comes up with a conclusion which is not accepted by the followers of other religions, they will reject his research and accuse him of negligence in the search or negligence, suspicion, love of the world, the desire for caprices. So, what is the value of the research if not capable and not guaranteed?! So easily, false religions and their corrupt doctrines and false evidence and their men crumble to shine the sun of atheism in the among humanity to let people know that atheism is an origin and that religion is a deviation which has not clear evidence and no right way to it?
Answer
In the name of Allah: be advised that any religion is divided into two parts: The first part is the theological issues that Allah provides reasonable proofs to his existence to meditate on any object of the world that can believe that such object is found alone without the creator of a world who is aware of the living being surrounding him and other beings. In this regard, Allah says, "We will show them our signs in the horizons and in themselves until they realize the truth." After faith in Allah Almighty and being wise due to the living beings’ indication on His wisdom that people cannot be left in vain. There must be a guide; all religions claim that their religion is right. However, Islam is the only religion that has the proof of Muhammad’s (PBUH&HF) prophethood. He (PBUH&HF) said: "The night of the Prophet (PBUH&HF) is the miracle of the Prophet (PBUH&HF) His doctrines from the first unification to its end. The second is related to the works in terms of rules and worship, so there are two ways of doing this. As for ijtihad or following the most knowledgeable living marji. Both ways are available according to the person's ability. The forbidden following is the following of parents in the fundamentals and branches. Then can any human live without a system that determines his behavior between himself and others, how can he live without a system? Wake up from your sleeping before the torment of Allah Almighty. Allah is the All Guide.
Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com
Suggest a correction or extra detail
Open to everyone — no account needed. A moderator reviews every suggestion.
Comments (0)
No comments yet.