Shia Online CommunityShia OnlineCommunity
⚖️

Najafi Q&A: Monotheism

lit 8/29/2026 · 18 entries · 0 followers · 0 likes

⚖️ Fiqh & LawJurist: Shaykh Bashir al-NajafiTopic: MonotheismMadhhab / school: Shia Ithna 'AshariyahSection: Theology (Aqa’id)#fiqh#najafi#qa

Q&AAllah, the Exalted, says: (To Him belongs the highest example in the heavens and the earth). What does this…

Allah, the Exalted, says: (To Him belongs the highest example in the heavens and the earth). What does this mean? I have heard from scholars that it means Allah has no mithl (likeness), but He has a mathal, and that this mathal refers to His Names. Is this correct?

Answer

In the name of Allah, Al-mathal is a means for establishing a correct meaning. Since Allah, Glorified is He, has signs (āyāt) on earth and even greater signs in the heavens, the mentioned verse refers to this meaning. This is also what is indicated by His saying,—“and indeed he saw of the greatest signs of his Lord”—when the Prophet (peace be upon him and his family) was taken up to the heavens during the Mi‘rāj. Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&ASomeone asked me to prove the existence of God, and the questions are as follows: 1.Who is God? 2.If He is a…

Someone asked me to prove the existence of God, and the questions are as follows: 1.Who is God? 2.If He is a God, then who created Him?

Answer

In the name of Allah, be informed, my son, that every rational person understands through their own conscience that anything we reflect upon is either contingent—meaning that it depends for its existence and continuation on a cause or an agent—or necessary in existence—meaning that it is self-sufficient and itself the source of existence. The beings we observe, including even night and day, fall into the first category: they are contingent beings. And it is not possible for something that is contingent to come into existence without a cause or agent. Therefore, this world and these beings must have a cause. That cause must be necessary in existence—completely independent and self-sufficient. If it too were in need of a cause to bring it into existence, then it would not be the ultimate cause. With this simple and clear explanation, every rational person can understand that the world must have a Creator who Himself is not in need of a creator—and that is Allah, Glorified and Exalted. Allah is the Guide, and He is All-Knowing.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AImam Hussain (PBUH) said: "Whoever worships Allah properly, Allah will grant him more than his hopes and…

Imam Hussain (PBUH) said: "Whoever worships Allah properly, Allah will grant him more than his hopes and suffice him." How can we worship Allah properly?

Answer

In the name of Allah, before worshiping, a person should understand the meaning of worship. Many times, people confuse obedience with worship, thinking that performing obligatory acts, recommended acts, and avoiding prohibited acts is the essence of worship, but this is incorrect. The first and foremost aspect of worship is submission and humility. There were people who worshiped idols, the sun, the moon, and other beings, but they did not obey their commands or prohibitions. Allah's words highlight this, as He says: "Do you worship besides Allah that which does not benefit you and does not harm you?" (Qur'an 35:14), and "Do you worship besides Allah that which has no power to harm you or benefit you? And Allah is the All-Hearing, All-Knowing" (Qur'an 35:40). Therefore, worship is primarily about submission and humility, and then compliance with Allah’s commands and prohibitions. A rational person obeys these after humbling himself before the worshiped One. These acts of worship indicate that the one performing them is submitting and humbling himself before the One whose commands and prohibitions he follows. There are many verses that challenge idolaters and their worship of other beings, forcing them to admit that these things do not benefit or harm them. Now, the true worship, as we have described, requires knowledge. There are two types of knowledge: the first, which is accessible to most people, is the knowledge of the Creator through reflection on His creations. The Qur'an encourages this type of knowledge for those who are deficient or unaware of the second kind of knowledge, as seen in verses like: "Do they not look at the camels, how they are created, and at the sky, how it is raised, and at the mountains, how they are set up, and at the earth, how it is spread out?" (Qur'an 88:17–20) and the words of Ibrahim (peace be upon him) to Nimrod: "Indeed, Allah brings the sun from the east, so bring it from the west." (Qur'an 2:258). This type of knowledge is available to anyone with basic intellect. The second type of knowledge is the knowledge of Allah’s essence without any intermediary, which is the true and ultimate knowledge. Allah may command His servant to attain this knowledge, as in the sacred hadith: "I was a hidden treasure and desired to be known, so I created creation to know Me." (This narration appears in multiple sources such as Rawdat al-Muttaqin 2:710, Bihar al-Anwar 84:344, and Sharh Usul al-Kafi by al-Mazandarani 1:229). This knowledge is granted to a person through the purification of the soul and its sanctification. This knowledge can be represented in the words of the scholars: it is like a mirror that is polished and free from dust, reflecting the images of things. Similarly, when a person's soul is purified, the essence of the Creator becomes visible to him, according to the purity and clarity of his soul. It is known that analogies bring us closer to understanding, but they also have limitations. And Allah is the Guide.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AHow can a believer monothize Allah and not associate anyone with Him, because Satan comes to some and the…

How can a believer monothize Allah and not associate anyone with Him, because Satan comes to some and the devilish whispers come to him that he worships other than Allah, such asking for the intercession of Ahlulbait (PBUT): 1. Are there some words that he can always iterate so that he becomes a monotheist before asking for Ahlulbait's (PBUH) intercession in order that it does not come to his mind that he (may Allah forbid) associates Ahlulbait (PBUT) with Allah. Asking for the intercession of Ahlulbait (PBUT) is not polytheism, but Satan comes in some moments and whispers to the believer that Ahlulbait (PBUT) are god other than Allah (may Allah forbid)? 2. What are these words and duas which the believer recites so that he becomes a monotheist then he asks for the intercession of Ahlulbait (PBUT) as he needs it. In this case, he wants to be sure that Allah has given him his need with the intercession of Ahlulbait (PBUT); it is from Almighty Allah and not from Ahlulbait (PBUT) without Allah?

Answer

In the name of Allah, monotheism meaning is illustrated in the saying "There is no god but Allah" and the Great Messenger (PBUH&HF) has come with that along with all the prophets; from Adam to the Great Prophet (PBUH&HF) and immaculate Imams (PBUT). The prophets were calling into this and still they are. It can be illustrated more in: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah, and I bear witness that He is Alone without partner. As for asking for the intercession of the Messenger (PBUH&HF) and his progeny (PBUT), it should be with the belief that they are the righteous servants of Allah. Allah granted them (PBUT) authority to intercede, so they intercede for those whom Allah is pleased with. Allah is the Guide.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AWhat does it mean for Satan to swear with Allah’s mighty after Satan rebelled against Allah?

What does it mean for Satan to swear with Allah’s mighty after Satan rebelled against Allah?

Answer

In the name of Allah, Satan disobeyed his Lord by not obeying Allah’s command to Satan. However, he did not disbelieve in Allah, meaning he did not abandon belief in Allah’s existence, ability, might, majesty and highness, but he disbelieved by abandoning compliance, like one of the soldiers who violates the commands of command out of ignorance, being ignorant or rebellion, but he believes in the leadership of the authority . Allah is the all Guide and Knowing.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AWhat are the influence and difference of being an integral part of religion or of the doctrine? How is it…

What are the influence and difference of being an integral part of religion or of the doctrine? How is it manifested in Quran and narrations? Is it manifested by means of strong emphasis or by warning the one who neglects the beliefs of torture? Or Is it a cornerstone which accepts no excuse from the one who abandons it?

Answer

A. In the name of Allah, the cornerstones of religion represent the beliefs which could expel one out of Islam if denying any of them. They are to believe in Allah’s onehood with His divine attributes, the Messenger’s prophethood, the Messenger is the last one, Quran is the book revealed by Allah and believing in the Day of Judgement. The one who denies any of these is a disbeliever [Kafir]. With regards to the fundamentals of the doctrine, they are the beliefs which could expel one out of the doctrine if denying any of them. The beliefs of the Shiite doctrine, in addition to the Islamic said ones, to believe in the twelve infallible Imams (PBUT), their infallibility, Lady Zahraa’s infallibility. All these are stipulated in the books of beliefs. Allah is the all Guide and Knowing.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AWhy is there a multiplicity in the heavenly religions? What is the wisdom of Allah? Why did not Islam, which…

Why is there a multiplicity in the heavenly religions? What is the wisdom of Allah? Why did not Islam, which is the true religion, be the message of the Messengers?

Answer

In the name of Allah, be advised that Allah says: “the religion of Allah is Islam”, “Ibrahim was not Jewish or Christian, he was a true Muslim”, and “the one who follows another religion than Islam will not be accepted”. Yes, there is a difference in the branches according to the willingness and authority of the people depending on the age of every prophet. This difference does not mean multiplicity of religion because it exists in one religious law. Allah is the All Guide and knowing.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AWhat are the effects that vary according to the rank of fundamentals and what is the evidence of the…

What are the effects that vary according to the rank of fundamentals and what is the evidence of the narrations on a certain fundamental?

Answer

In the name of Allah, the fundamentals are not different in the area that we have referred to. Yes, there is a ranking system between these fundamentals. Unification (Monotheism) is fronted to all. Then, the Prophethood, then the Day of Judgement. This is in terms of the fundamentals of the religion and of the doctrine. It is added to the unification, justice, then the prophecy and then the imamate. This ranking is based on the dependence of the latter on the former. It is not logical to depend on the latter without depending on the former. Allah is the All Guide and knowing.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AAre the fundamentals regarded as one rank in the religious knowledge or more?

Are the fundamentals regarded as one rank in the religious knowledge or more?

Answer

In the name of Allah, the rejection of any one who makes the rejecter out of Islam (if he denies anything of the fundamentals of Islam) and makes him out of the doctrine, if he denied something of the fundamentals of the doctrine. This is the common denominator between the fundamentals of religion as well as the fundamentals of the doctrine. Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AIs the distinction between Allah and His creatures is the differentiation of the thing from the other thing…

Is the distinction between Allah and His creatures is the differentiation of the thing from the other thing or the distinctions of attribute as some believe relying on the words of the Imam of the Faithful (PBUH): the distinction is a matter of attribute not separating characteristics?

Answer

In the name of Allah, the Imam (PBUH) says that there is no limit between the Creator and the creature; between the Creator and the body. So, it is necessary for Allah to be limited. Therefore, the Imam (PBUH) said in one of his sermons “He [Allah] has neither defining limit nor limited attribute”. The purpose of the description of the attribute that it is an obligation and other is possible. Allah is a creator and the other is created. Allah is worshipped, while the other is a slave. Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&ADo the names of Allah represent Him?

Do the names of Allah represent Him?

Answer

In the name of Allah: they are three parts: the first is what is used to refer to Him as “Allah”, the second is used as attributes to Him such as the knowing, the able… etc., and the third signifies His actions, such as creator and the provider. Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AHow would you prove Allah's existence to an atheist?

How would you prove Allah's existence to an atheist?

Answer

In the name of Allah: If he has a mind, it is sufficient to alert him that as no action takes place without a worker and without any maker, the world cannot exist without the maker of a great world. In such a way, Allah’s closest friend the prophet Ibrahim (PBUH) encountered the tyrant of his time, saying to the tyrant: (Allah brings in the sun from the east. Can you bring it from the west? And the disbeliever was disappointed). Allah is the All Guide and knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&A(And Allah is the best of the providers) (Allah is blessing, the best among creators) (best) and (best) used…

(And Allah is the best of the providers) (Allah is blessing, the best among creators) (best) and (best) used in the language of preference may be apparently understood from the context of what is mentioned in the Quran that there is more than one provider and more than one creator. Why is the mention of the two types in plural rather than singular?

Answer

In the name of Allah, this can be explained by one of the two things: The first: Allah Almighty makes the providence of some people under the hands of others. The laymen imagine that Allah Almighty makes their providence under the hands of some people, but Allah Almighty in these verses shows that He is the best among these people whom other people think that they the providers. The second is that Allah is the best provider and the best creator, among all who could be as creator and provider and all that if the word “good” in the verses comes in the sense of the name of preference. It can be an attribute where there is no what to doubt then. It can be inferred from some of the narrations in the interpretation of Allah Akbar that Allah is the best of the merciful and the best Creator in the sense that it is better to be described as great because everything that comes in the mind of the descriptor is without reality and Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AIs the first law of thermodynamics true? It states that energy is not destroyed and not developed, but…

Is the first law of thermodynamics true? It states that energy is not destroyed and not developed, but transformed from one form to another. Thus, the atheists say according to this law that the universe has neither a beginning nor an end and it is eternal and does not need the Creator, Allah forbid.

Answer

Regarding the thermal energy that you mentioned, my son, is it aware of or learning what it is doing and turning from one situation to another by self-influencing factor or by others influencing it? If it is aware of and learns what we do, it chooses what is right and leaves what is not. Such energy will not be a material thing. Materials are free of these receptive qualities. If it is free from the perception, how to move in the right direction if the movement is by itself. It exhausts the mind. So, how could a thing affect itself? Can it be found by itself with all its properties? If there is what moves and manages the thing, then we move to query: what is that engine and director? Be advised, my son, that the heart in animals and humans pushes the blood into the veins and to the limbs of the body. It is known that each of the limbs such as the hand, for all the parts of this part, needs nutrition and nutrition of each part does not suit the nutrition of the other. We can know that through the simplest example that if a bone is affected, it needs medicine; if the skin is affected, it needs another medicine and so as the Hair, the nails, and veins need different types of medicine. We understand that the food of each is different because the reality that each one is different from the other. How can the blood be in a single tube and the food is not different from each other? What is the hidden force that may divide these foods, giving each part no matter how small or thin food and return food to the center of the heart and so in all organisms? Can any energy feed one family with one tube? How can we say that unconscious energy can do all such feeding? Allah is the All Guide and knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AIt is well known that Satan is a sinner, all evil. When we seek refuge from the accursed Satan is it correct…

It is well known that Satan is a sinner, all evil. When we seek refuge from the accursed Satan is it correct to say this phrase is "I seek refuge in Allah from the evil of the sinful Satan?"

Answer

In the name of Allah, this formula is correct in terms of meaning and according to the general commands to seek refuge in Allah from the evil of Satan, but the best is to follow the infallible Imams (peace be upon them) (I seek refuge in Allah from the accursed Satan). Allah knows best.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AHow do you respond to this reasoning: If we ask: What does Allah want from people? Through which way does He…

How do you respond to this reasoning: If we ask: What does Allah want from people? Through which way does He want them to worship him? We find no religion to us except two ways: the first is to follow a religious authority (marji) and the second is to research and be a mujtahid. There is no other way of religion. This means that Allah wants one of these two according to the logic of the religious. As for following a marji, there is no doubt that there is no suspicion about its nullity, and that is the consensus of the religion scholars and others. It is not possible that Allah wants the sons of every religion to follow their fathers in their religion. All that remains is the need to seek out the true religion and to be religious. However, the search for true religion requires conditions that are not available in any one: It is necessary to study all contemporary and ancient religious schools and religions and study them in depth, to know their confessions, to compare their scholars, and to balance the statements of each religion with each other. This study requires studying the sciences, literature, languages, reading books, criticizing them, comparing them, and saving travel costs, research costs, and purchasing books with the time and qualities that must be available in the researcher such as science, mind, dream, honesty and patience. This is what great men cannot do throughout their lives. It is absolutely impossible How to ask adolescent children in puberty?! The jurists have decided in their jurisprudential research that the disability nullifies the commitment. Searching for the true religion is not obligatory because it is not possible. If the obligation to seek the religion is nullified, then the religion must be nullified too. Thus, you will get from the above that the religious has got only two options, not the other: either following a marji and it is in addition to nullification we make sure that Allah does not want and does not ask anyone to follow his people in their religion. Or searching for the true religion with its proper conditions, a matter which is absolutely inconceivable. This means that Allah does not want anyone to be religious at all with any religion ... If Allah wanted people to have a particular religion, why has not he made them a true path, : as mentioned in the Quranic verse: (And there is no embarrassment on you in religion) and any greater embarrassment than we are asking a true, easy path to religion, we do not find! If we recognize that the search for religion is the right way to religion because we do not agree on that; the search for the right religion is not a true path and not safe for religion because the researcher is not an infallible and the occurrence in error, negligence, suspicion and the predominance of instincts and desires are possible. If a researcher searches for the right religion and comes up with a conclusion which is not accepted by the followers of other religions, they will reject his research and accuse him of negligence in the search or negligence, suspicion, love of the world, the desire for caprices. So, what is the value of the research if not capable and not guaranteed?! So easily, false religions and their corrupt doctrines and false evidence and their men crumble to shine the sun of atheism in the among humanity to let people know that atheism is an origin and that religion is a deviation which has not clear evidence and no right way to it?

Answer

In the name of Allah: be advised that any religion is divided into two parts: The first part is the theological issues that Allah provides reasonable proofs to his existence to meditate on any object of the world that can believe that such object is found alone without the creator of a world who is aware of the living being surrounding him and other beings. In this regard, Allah says, "We will show them our signs in the horizons and in themselves until they realize the truth." After faith in Allah Almighty and being wise due to the living beings’ indication on His wisdom that people cannot be left in vain. There must be a guide; all religions claim that their religion is right. However, Islam is the only religion that has the proof of Muhammad’s (PBUH&HF) prophethood. He (PBUH&HF) said: "The night of the Prophet (PBUH&HF) is the miracle of the Prophet (PBUH&HF) His doctrines from the first unification to its end. The second is related to the works in terms of rules and worship, so there are two ways of doing this. As for ijtihad or following the most knowledgeable living marji. Both ways are available according to the person's ability. The forbidden following is the following of parents in the fundamentals and branches. Then can any human live without a system that determines his behavior between himself and others, how can he live without a system? Wake up from your sleeping before the torment of Allah Almighty. Allah is the All Guide.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Q&AThere is a problem which is how to apply the Islamic laws 1400 years ago now after the passage of this time…

There is a problem which is how to apply the Islamic laws 1400 years ago now after the passage of this time which is very large since the human now is different from the human 1400 years ago.

Answer

In the name of Allah, the laws that humans create are meant to handle the circumstances of life and the society. However, the laws stipulated by the Creator of the creatures are put forth, and He declared that this law is permanent. This does not mean that such that the Shari'a- as it were- was not benefiting from the circumstances that prevailed at the time of legislation. I want you to state one case that cannot be addressed in the light of the Jaafari religious rules so that I can permit you such a non-Muslim claim. Allah is the All Guide.

Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com

Engagement · last 1 day

Likes · 0

Comments · 0

Followers · 0

Sign in to add audio, video, text or references to this wick.